Peer Review Process

1. Review Policy

The Journal of Sport Education, Biomechanics, Athletics, Fitness, Health and Recreation (JEBAFR) implements a double-blind peer-review system to ensure the quality, originality, validity, and scientific contribution of all manuscripts submitted for publication.

Under this system, the identities of authors and reviewers are kept confidential throughout the review process. Each manuscript that passes the initial editorial screening is evaluated by at least two independent reviewers who have relevant academic expertise in the subject area.

The peer-review process aims to maintain academic integrity, ensure scientific rigor, and provide constructive feedback to improve the quality of submitted manuscripts.

2. Review Stages

The manuscript evaluation process consists of the following stages:

Stage 1: Manuscript Submission

Authors submit their manuscripts through the JEBAFR Online Journal System (OJS). Submissions must comply with the journal's author guidelines, formatting requirements, ethical standards, and publication policies.

Stage 2: Initial Editorial Screening

The editor conducts an initial assessment to examine:

  • Relevance to the journal's Focus and Scope.

  • Compliance with manuscript preparation guidelines.

  • Originality and similarity screening.

  • Completeness of manuscript components.

  • Compliance with publication ethics.

Manuscripts that do not meet the journal's requirements may be returned to authors for technical corrections or rejected without external review.

Stage 3: Reviewer Assignment

Manuscripts that pass the initial screening are assigned to at least two independent reviewers with expertise relevant to the manuscript's subject area.

The editorial team ensures that reviewers have no identifiable conflicts of interest with the authors or the submitted research.

Stage 4: Peer Review Evaluation

Reviewers critically evaluate manuscripts based on the following criteria:

  • Originality and scientific contribution.

  • Relevance and clarity of research objectives.

  • Theoretical framework and literature review.

  • Appropriateness of research design and methodology.

  • Validity of instruments and data analysis.

  • Accuracy and clarity of results.

  • Quality of discussion and interpretation.

  • Conclusions, implications, and recommendations.

  • Quality and relevance of references.

Reviewers provide constructive comments and recommendations through the OJS review system.

Stage 5: Editorial Decision

Based on the reviewers' evaluations, the editor makes one of the following decisions:

  1. Accept: The manuscript is accepted for publication without further substantive revisions.

  2. Minor Revision: The manuscript requires minor corrections before acceptance.

  3. Major Revision: The manuscript requires substantial revisions and may undergo another round of review.

  4. Reject: The manuscript does not meet the journal's scientific or editorial standards.

The final decision rests with the Editor-in-Chief or the authorized editor.

Stage 6: Manuscript Revision

Authors are required to revise their manuscripts according to the reviewers' and editor's comments. A point-by-point response to all reviewer comments must accompany the revised manuscript.

Authors should clearly indicate the changes made and provide scientific justifications for any comments they do not adopt.

Stage 7: Final Evaluation

The revised manuscript is evaluated by the editor and, when necessary, returned to the original reviewers for further assessment.

The editor verifies whether all essential revisions have been adequately addressed before making the final publication decision.

Stage 8: Copyediting and Production

Accepted manuscripts proceed to copyediting, proofreading, layout editing, and final publication preparation. Authors may be asked to verify the final galley proof before publication.

Stage 9: Publication

The finalized manuscript is published online through the JEBAFR OJS platform as part of the scheduled journal issue.

3. Review Timeline

JEBAFR aims to maintain an efficient and transparent review process. The following timeline represents the journal's target processing periods.

Review Stage Target Duration
Initial Editorial Screening 3–7 days
Reviewer Assignment 3–7 days
Peer Review Process 14–21 days
Author Revision 7–14 days
Final Editorial Evaluation 3–7 days
Copyediting and Production 7–14 days

The overall publication timeline may vary depending on manuscript quality, reviewer availability, revision requirements, and editorial workload.

4. Review Confidentiality

JEBAFR strictly maintains the confidentiality of manuscripts throughout the peer-review process. Reviewers must not disclose, distribute, or use unpublished information from submitted manuscripts for personal or professional purposes.

Authors and reviewers are expected to respect the principles of academic integrity, transparency, and professional conduct.

5. Conflict of Interest

Reviewers must declare any potential conflicts of interest before accepting a review assignment. Reviewers should decline invitations if personal, professional, financial, or academic relationships could compromise their objectivity.

The editorial team is responsible for assigning alternative reviewers when necessary.

6. Appeals and Complaints

Authors who disagree with an editorial decision may submit a formal appeal to the editorial office, accompanied by clear scientific arguments and supporting evidence.

All appeals and complaints are evaluated fairly and independently by the editorial team. The journal may seek additional expert opinions when necessary.

7. Commitment to Quality

JEBAFR is committed to ensuring that all published manuscripts meet appropriate standards of originality, methodological rigor, scientific relevance, and academic integrity.

Through a rigorous and transparent double-blind peer-review process, JEBAFR seeks to contribute to the advancement of knowledge and research excellence in sport education, biomechanics, athletics, fitness, health, and recreation.