Peer Reviewers
Peer Reviewers
1. Reviewer Qualifications
Peer reviewers of the Journal of Sport Education, Biomechanics, Athletics, Fitness, Health and Recreation (JEBAFR) are selected based on their academic qualifications, research expertise, professional experience, and contributions to the development of scientific knowledge in relevant fields.
Reviewers are expected to meet the following qualifications:
-
Hold a doctoral degree (Ph.D. or equivalent) or demonstrate recognized expertise and substantial research experience in the relevant field.
-
Have expertise in one or more areas covered by the journal's Focus and Scope.
-
Possess a strong academic and research background, preferably demonstrated through publications in reputable national or international scientific journals.
-
Have experience in conducting research, academic writing, and scientific publication.
-
Demonstrate the ability to critically evaluate research methodology, data analysis, scientific validity, originality, and scholarly contributions.
-
Maintain academic integrity, professionalism, and objectivity throughout the review process.
2. Reviewer Responsibilities
Peer reviewers play an essential role in maintaining the scientific quality and integrity of JEBAFR publications. Reviewers are responsible for:
-
Evaluating the originality, relevance, and scientific contribution of submitted manuscripts.
-
Assessing the clarity and consistency of the research objectives, theoretical framework, and literature review.
-
Evaluating the appropriateness and rigor of research methodologies, instruments, sampling procedures, and data analysis.
-
Examining the accuracy, validity, and interpretation of research findings.
-
Providing constructive, objective, and evidence-based comments to improve manuscript quality.
-
Identifying potential ethical concerns, including plagiarism, data fabrication, falsification, and inappropriate citation practices.
-
Providing clear recommendations regarding manuscript acceptance, revision, or rejection.
-
Completing the review within the assigned timeframe.
3. Peer Review Process
JEBAFR applies a double-blind peer-review process, in which the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from each other throughout the review process.
The review process consists of the following stages:
-
Initial Editorial Screening: The editor evaluates the manuscript's suitability, originality, completeness, and compliance with the journal's submission guidelines.
-
Reviewer Assignment: Manuscripts passing the initial screening are assigned to at least two independent reviewers with relevant expertise.
-
Peer Review Evaluation: Reviewers assess the manuscript's scientific quality, methodology, originality, relevance, and contribution to the field.
-
Editorial Decision: Based on the reviewers' recommendations, the editor makes the final decision regarding publication.
-
Revision Process: Authors are required to address reviewers' comments and submit a revised manuscript when revisions are requested.
-
Final Evaluation: The editor evaluates the revised manuscript to determine whether it meets the journal's publication standards.
4. Reviewer Recommendations
Reviewers are expected to provide one of the following recommendations:
-
Accept Submission: The manuscript meets the journal's academic and publication standards and requires no substantial revisions.
-
Accept with Minor Revisions: The manuscript is suitable for publication after minor corrections.
-
Major Revisions: The manuscript requires substantial improvements before it can be considered for publication.
-
Reject Submission: The manuscript does not meet the journal's scientific, methodological, or editorial standards.
The final publication decision rests with the Editor-in-Chief or authorized editor, taking into consideration the reviewers' comments and recommendations.
5. Ethical Guidelines for Reviewers
Reviewers must adhere to the following ethical principles:
-
Confidentiality: Manuscripts under review must be treated as confidential documents and must not be shared or disclosed to unauthorized individuals.
-
Objectivity: Reviews must be conducted objectively, fairly, and professionally, without personal bias or discriminatory judgments.
-
Conflict of Interest: Reviewers must disclose any potential conflicts of interest and decline assignments when impartiality may be compromised.
-
Academic Integrity: Reviewers must report suspected plagiarism, duplicate publication, data manipulation, or other forms of research misconduct to the editor.
-
Confidential Use of Information: Unpublished information obtained during peer review must not be used for personal research or professional advantage.
-
Constructive Feedback: Reviewers should provide respectful, specific, and constructive recommendations to improve the scientific quality of manuscripts.
6. Review Timeline
JEBAFR encourages reviewers to complete manuscript evaluations within 14–21 days after accepting a review invitation. If additional time is required, reviewers should inform the editorial office as early as possible.
7. Reviewer Recognition
JEBAFR recognizes the valuable contributions of peer reviewers in maintaining the quality and credibility of scientific publications. Reviewer contributions may be acknowledged through:
-
Official reviewer certificates.
-
Recognition on the journal's website, subject to reviewer consent.
-
Inclusion in the journal's annual reviewer acknowledgement.
-
Opportunities for future academic collaboration and editorial activities.
8. Commitment to Publication Quality
JEBAFR is committed to maintaining high standards of academic excellence, transparency, and publication ethics. The journal values the professional contributions of reviewers and recognizes their essential role in advancing scientific research in sport education, biomechanics, athletics, fitness, health, and recreation.



